The main issue in dispute centers on the concept of "Cypriotness." One faction argues for an interpretation that closely aligns with the rhetoric of the Republic of Cyprus (RoC). They view all residents of northern Cyprus with Anatolian origins as illegal inhabitants, claiming that they came to the island following the Turkish military invasion and occupation in 1974.
In contrast, another segment of the left holds an opposing view, arguing that individuals of Turkish origin who settled in the north after 1974 have become an integral part of the island's diverse mosaic. They also emphasize that these individuals are allies of the island's working class in their struggles against the bourgeoisie. This group contends that overlooking this complex reality hinders a proper understanding of modern Turkish Cypriot identity.
Recent ideological battles with deep roots have erupted on social media, highlighting significant divisions. For example, Turkish Cypriot politician and activist Murat Kanatlı recently made a cutting remark, likening advocates for this diverse, post-1974 Turkish Cypriot identity to "Cyprus's Doğu Perinçek," referencing a Turkish ultra-nationalist leader and implying an unwelcome ideological import.
Simultaneously, a particularly sharp exchange involved Bağımsızlık Yolu's (Road of Independence) Münür Rahvancıoğlu and Şener Levent, General Editor of the opposition newspaper Avrupa. Rahvancıoğlu accused Avrupa of being a "satellite" for the "fascist mentality governing the Republic of Cyprus," claiming Levent "only knows states... [and] cannot see 'people'." Rahvancıoğlu asserted Levent indiscriminately labels diverse protesters (including those from Azerbaijan or Morocco) as "Turks," and championed a "human-centric" view where "LOVE, not states, will win." He criticized Levent for, in his view, defending RoC policies on children's rights by deflecting to Turkey's actions.
Şener Levent retorted sharply, asking, "What is this delirium, Münür?" He denied ever opposing RoC citizenship for children of mixed heritage, claiming he "was the one who made the first attempt" for it. Levent also distanced himself from the TRNC's establishment, stating, "I did not establish the TRNC... I was just a journalist." He clarified his newspaper's recent controversial headline, which prompted Rahvancıoğlu to criticize him for merely questioning why Greek Cypriots cannot protest in the North like Turkish Cypriots do. He cautioned Rahvancıoğlu against casually labeling dissenters as "fascist," asking, "Has fascism become so trivial?"
The fracturing of this opposition front signals a significant setback for those seeking to present a united Turkish Cypriot stance on critical local issues, navigate the complex relationship with Turkey, and secure the island's future, just months before the crucial Turkish Cypriot presidential elections.